Modern Innovations Universal Lid Best Overall
- Fits
- 8.25, 9, 10, 11, 12 in
- Material
- 18/8 stainless steel, glass
- Heat Resistance
- Up to 425°F
- Overall Diameter
- 12.5 in
The rim is pressed into five concentric steps, and each one seats a different diameter: 8.25, 9, 10, 11, or 12 inches. That beats a flexible edge that has to be squashed into place, because a step sits flat on the pot's rim rather than curling around it. There's no silicone to stretch out or hold onto the smell of last night's onions, and we paid close attention to the handle, because nothing here is threaded through glass — the part that gives out first on several lids in this roundup.
Underneath is 18/8 stainless steel with a tempered glass center and a vent hole that lets moisture escape instead of raining back into the pan. The whole thing is rated to 425°F, which puts it among the few lids here you can move from a burner straight into the oven to finish a pan of chicken thighs. The steel handle is roomy enough for a thick oven mitt, and it gets hot — treat it like a skillet handle and keep a dry towel within reach.
The compromise is the seal. Steel rests on the rim instead of gripping it, so this covers and vents rather than clamping down, and on the small 8.25-inch setting it's a wide lid perched on a small pan. What you get in return is a lid with almost nothing to fail: no knob screw to re-tighten, no silicone lip to tear, and a shape that stacks flat in the cabinet.
What We Like
- One lid seats five diameters, 8.25 to 12 inches
- Stated oven rating of 425°F
- No knob screw or silicone rim to fail
Worth Noting
- Steel rim rests rather than seals
- Oversized on an 8.25-inch pan
This is the lid we hand people first: five diameters in one piece of steel and glass, rated to 425°F, with no knob screw to work loose.
Check Latest Price