Lodge Round Cast Iron Griddle Best Overall
- Weight
- 4.7 lb
- Diameter
- 10.5 inches
- Material
- Cast iron
- Oven Safe
- 650 °F
Ten and a half inches is the number that decides this one. That circle sits on a single burner with nothing hanging past the grate, which is more than most griddles can say — a wide plate is useless on a cramped range where the next ring is already taken. We cooked pancakes, eggs, and burgers on it, and what struck us is how little the surface cares what lands on it: cast iron soaks up heat and releases it slowly, so cold batter does not flatten the temperature. For a household of one or two, this is where we point first.
It arrives seasoned, which is not the same as nonstick, and the first week tells you so. Eggs want a film of butter or oil and a properly hot pan; the surface gets slicker every time you cook something fatty in it. In exchange you get a finish that shrugs off a metal spatula, a hard scrape, and a stiff brush, and there is no coating to wonder about. We take that trade — a little more fat and attention for a pan that will not delaminate on you.
The stub handle is the one thing that annoys us in use: it heats right along with the pan, so a folded towel lives beside the stove whenever this is out. Otherwise it moves from burner to a 650 °F oven to a grill to a campfire without complaint, and it moonlights as a tortilla warmer and a crepe pan. At under five pounds it shifts with one hand while the other holds a spatula.
The real limit is batch size. Two or three pancakes at a time is realistic, and a family of four will stand at the stove a while. If that is your household, the two-burner plates below solve it. If it is not, this is the piece that will still be in the cabinet long after every nonstick pan you have owned has gone.
What We Like
- Clears a single burner with no overhang
- Cast iron holds heat through a whole batch
- No coating to scratch or question
Worth Noting
- Slow to respond when you drop the heat
- Two or three pancakes per batch at most
The best default here for anyone cooking for one or two: a ten-and-a-half-inch round that clears a single burner, holds heat through a batch, and has no coating to wear out.
Check Latest Price